Shelby Hayes

The Coverage Consultants
112 Kingston Lane
Canton, GA 30115
Mobile: 770-241-5767
Introduction

Shelby King Hayes, CIC, CPRM, AAI, is the Founder and Principal Consultant of The Coverage Consultants, an independent insurance coverage and risk management practice based in Canton, Georgia, serving clients and matters nationwide. With more than twenty years of property and casualty insurance experience, Ms. Hayes provides expert analysis, consulting, and testimony in matters involving insurance coverage, policy interpretation, coverage adequacy, agent and broker standard of care, procurement and placement of insurance, and errors and omissions exposure.

Ms. Hayes brings an unusually broad agency-side perspective to insurance disputes. Her career includes fourteen years managing a book of more than 2,200 personal and commercial lines clients, advancement into high net worth personal risk production, and senior leadership responsibilities in agency sales, operations, and client service. Her experience encompasses the practical mechanics of insurance placement from initial exposure identification and application through quoting, underwriting, binding, policy issuance, endorsement, renewal, and ongoing account servicing.

In expert and consulting engagements, Ms. Hayes reviews policies and endorsements, underwriting files, applications, binders, proposals, certificates of insurance, correspondence, coverage recommendations, renewal documentation, and agency records to reconstruct how coverage was requested, represented, placed, and maintained. She evaluates those facts against applicable policy language, ISO and proprietary forms, carrier underwriting and binding guidelines, agency practices, applicable statutes and regulations, and the duties and standards relevant to insurance professionals.

Ms. Hayes also maintains a specialized practice involving condominium and homeowners association insurance. These matters frequently require analysis beyond the master policy itself, including the interaction among governing documents, association insurance requirements, master policy provisions, and individual unit owner coverage. She reviews declarations, CC&Rs, bylaws, master policies, endorsements, reserve studies, financial information, and related records to identify coverage responsibilities, gaps, overlaps, valuation concerns, and potential deficiencies in insurance placement.

Her condominium and HOA work includes master policy gap analysis and HO-3/HO-6 allocation analysis, as well as evaluation of property, general liability, directors and officers liability, crime and fidelity, equipment breakdown, ordinance or law, flood, workers compensation, cyber, and excess liability exposures. She has developed proprietary, repeatable methodologies for evaluating community association insurance programs, including a weighted coverage-grading framework and comprehensive master policy analysis platform designed to assess coverage structure, responsibility allocation, and insurance adequacy consistently across associations.

Ms. Hayes holds the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC), Certified Personal Risk Manager (CPRM), and Accredited Advisor in Insurance (AAI) professional designations and is a licensed property and casualty insurance professional in Georgia. She earned a Bachelor of Arts in Psychology from Georgia State University. She is also a published insurance industry contributor, including publication in the Private Risk Management Association's Member Perspectives addressing artificial intelligence, social media, and the evolving personal risk landscape.

As an independent, non-commissioned consultant, Ms. Hayes does not represent an insurance carrier, and her coverage analysis is conducted independently of insurer or agency compensation. Her work focuses on the insurance contract, the underlying documentation, applicable professional practices, and the specific facts surrounding the procurement and servicing of coverage.

Ms. Hayes is available for case screening and pre-litigation consulting, policy and endorsement analysis, agent and broker standard-of-care review, coverage adequacy analysis, file and chronology reconstruction, written expert reports, deposition preparation, mediation and settlement support, and consulting or testifying expert engagements. She is also available to present on insurance fundamentals, coverage disputes, agent E&O exposure, condominium and HOA insurance, high net worth personal risk, and emerging insurance issues, including CLE programs.


Areas of Expertise
  • Auto Insurance
  • Bad Faith
  • Homeowner's Insurance
  • Insurance - General
  • Insurance Agency
  • Insurance Agent/Broker
  • Insurance Customs & Practices
  • Insurance Excess & Surplus Lines
  • Insurance Fraud
  • Risk Management

Expert Background
Q: Please list your professional accreditations, degrees, licenses, and certificates granted:
A: Professional Accreditations & Designations
Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC)
Certified Personal Risk Manager (CPRM)
Accredited Advisor in Insurance (AAI)

Licenses
Resident Counselor– State of Georgia
Counselor-Casualty
Counselor- Property

Professional Experience
Nearly two decades of experience in property and casualty insurance, coverage analysis, compliance, and agency standards of care
Q: Please list your affiliations or memberships in any professional and/or industry organizations:
A: Professional & Industry Affiliations
Private Risk Management Association (PRMA)
Risk & Insurance Management Society (RIMS)
National Alliance for Insurance Education & Research
Q: Have any of your accreditations ever been investigated, suspended or removed? (if yes, explain)
A: No
Q: What services do you offer? (E.g.: consulting, testing, reports, site inspections etc.)
A: Insurance Coverage Analysis and Policy Interpretation
Consulting and Testifying Expert Witness Services
Insurance Agent, Broker, and Producer Standard of Care Analysis
Agent and Broker Errors & Omissions (E&O) Analysis
Failure to Procure and Coverage Adequacy Analysis
Insurance Agency and Broker Practice Reviews
Policy, Endorsement, Exclusion, and ISO Form Analysis
Underwriting, Binding, and Insurance Placement Analysis
HOA and Condominium Master Policy Analysis
HO-3 / HO-6 and Association vs. Unit Owner Coverage Analysis
CC&R and Governing Document Insurance Analysis
Certificate of Insurance (COI) and Additional Insured Analysis
Coverage Gap, Underinsurance, and Limit Adequacy Analysis
Insurance File and Document Review
Chronology and Coverage Reconstruction
Pre-Litigation Case Screening and Consulting
Litigation Support and Case Analysis
Written Expert and Rebuttal Reports
Deposition Preparation and Testimony
Mediation and Settlement Support
Trial Testimony
Q: What is your hourly rate to consult with an attorney?
A: $150
Q: What is your hourly rate to review documents?
A: $200
Q: What is your hourly rate to provide deposition testimony?
A: $350: 4 hour minimum
Q: What is your hourly rate to provide testimony at trial?
A: $3,000 per day


References

Available Upon Request